Claims by Associate Professor Solehah Yaacob of the International Islamic University Malaysia have sparked extensive debate following her assertion that ancient Romans adopted shipbuilding techniques from Malay seafarers. During her lecture titled “Rome Learned to Build Ships From Malays,” Solehah argued that the advanced maritime practices of the Malay civilization influenced Roman naval technology, presenting her views in connection with broader discussions about Southeast Asia's maritime legacy.

The presentation immediately divided opinions, with some expressing national pride at Malaysia’s seafaring heritage, while others questioned the historical basis of such claims. Roman boats predominantly featured a rigid plank-on-frame design, which contrasted sharply with Malay vessels built using flexible lashed-lug or sewn-plank techniques, tailored to tropical marine conditions. Critics contend that these fundamental differences make the assertion unlikely, despite the recognised navigational prowess of Malay sailors, who historically traversed vast distances in the Indian Ocean and South China Sea.

Social media commentary on Solehah’s lecture has been polarizing, with sarcasm and skepticism dominating online discussions. Many users have raised concerns about the academic rigor of her presentation, particularly given Solehah’s upcoming bid for a full professorship. Calls for evidence and references to substantiate the claims have emerged, with some questioning her authority to draw connections between Malay boatbuilding traditions and Roman naval practices.

During her lecture, Solehah’s focus extended beyond shipbuilding techniques to highlight Southeast Asia's contributions as a historically significant hub of innovation and trade. She cited historical artefacts and records of correspondence between ancient civilizations, aiming to reposition Southeast Asia alongside historically recognized cradles of civilization such as Mesopotamia and Ancient Egypt. Her arguments also come amid renewed academic interest in Malay maritime history, following the discovery of a centuries-old shipwreck off the coast of Melaka earlier this year.

Why this matters

Solehah’s claim challenges existing maritime historical narratives that traditionally center around Mediterranean civilizations, opening a broader discussion about the interconnectedness of ancient seafaring communities and their technological exchanges. However, under scrutiny, the assertion highlights the tension between local heritage promotion and historical accuracy. For maritime historians and shipbuilders, this debate reminds the industry of the importance of maintaining credible evidence-based analysis when revising historical perspectives.

The prospect of repositioning Southeast Asia as a significant maritime hub has operational implications for shipowners, academic institutions, and cultural stakeholders in the region. Elevated emphasis on Malay seafaring heritage could propel Malaysia into a more prominent role in global maritime historical research and tourism, potentially leveraging discoveries like Melaka’s shipwreck to bolster international collaborations.

As academic and public discourse on the topic continues, the controversy underscores the balance required between celebrating national maritime heritage and adhering to rigorous scholarly criteria. Moving forward, the debate raises key questions for Malaysia’s academic institutions about how to responsibly incorporate heritage claims into historical analysis while ensuring global scholarly integrity. Observers will be watching if further archaeological findings or peer-reviewed studies lend weight to Solehah’s assertions, shifting the debate from speculation to compelling evidence.